Another Study

A group called The Physicians’ Foundation came out with yet more evidence (check it out here) supporting what you probably hear from most of the MedBlog community in different forms all the time.  If you read my blog regularly, you’re probably also aware of some of my cyber-colleagues like Kevin M.D., Dr. Wes, The Happy Hospitalist, Fat Doctor, Shadowfax and others espousing similar concerns.

We’ve all talked about how primary care is becoming untenable.  Now there’s a questionnaire survey that was mailed to every primary care doctor in the country, and it backs up our claims too, essentially asserting:

Primary care medicine sucks if you can’t spend time with your patients.

We didn’t go into medicine (and enormous debt) to do paperwork and argue with insurance companies.  People who do paperwork and filing for a living don’t understand our intolerance for their way of life, but it’s a fact that not everyone likes the sterile confines of alphabetization, algorithms and cubicles.

Some argue that the answer is more allied-health providers for primary care, like N.P.’s, Dr. Nurses (weird one, I know), P.A.’s, etc.  I disagree.  Excellent health systems provide excellent health care, and that starts with well-trained providers with doctorate-level education.

Residency-trained family medicine doctors average 12 THOUSAND hours of training before practice.  Nurse Practitioners average around 3500 hours.  Same for P.A.’s.  These people are easily as intellectually-equipped as doctors, but I think the idea that they are as well trained or can replace physicians is ludicrous.

I also hope lawmakers intent on saving our system don’t rush to the EMR (electronic medical record) as the messiah of American medicine.  It isn’t.  I use one every day, and it does very little to improve care and absolutely nothing to improve efficiency.  If EVERY doctor used an EMR that talked to all other EMR’s, efficiency might improve somewhat.  But our capitalist system has provided us with dozens of competing companies and, given our obsession with medical privacy, none of these programs communicate with each other.  Digital charting takes hours and is only slightly improved by hacking away on the keyboard during the entire patient encounter, detailing everything as it happens.

And, for a future blog, those records do nothing to protect doctors from litigation.  Trust me.  Nothing.  If anything, they help the plaintiff.

Also on the EMR topic, it is colossally more expensive to sustain than just some basic paper and dictated notes.  Companies LOVE the idea of EMR’s because the required tech support, and database maintenance, and program upgrade requirements are virtual gold mines.  In the end though, it’s another of thousands of examples of business and enterprise making money on medicine – the real reason American medicine is falling apart.

Like the canary in the coal mine, as Family Medicine goes, so goes American health care.  If well-trained doctors are getting out of the business, the natural corollary is that you, over time, will be getting sicker (and poorer).

2 thoughts on “Another Study

  1. Given that all I know is my experience as a patient, let me tell you how invaluable I find the excellent care of my PCP/internist. Thanks to his insistence on spending time (*wisely* — I know not to waste his time!) with me, I’m still kicking!

    Recently, the situation you describe just became too much for him, and he left a thriving and established practice to open a (so-called) concierge practice. I am pretty poor — but his value can’t be priced, so we scraped together the yearly fee, and will make that a priority, second only to the mortgage in future years.

    Get this, though: Not knowing that I had already paid, he offered me the equivalent of a scholarship. I’ve never been so humbled but hope that my reasons for not accepting are clear to him. Every relationship needs boundaries.

    I hope that somewhere in the morass that is our future, the profound problems facing the medical profession will be matched with caring and humane solutions.


  2. secretwave101

    BC –

    Although it sounds self-serving, given my profession I applaud you for allocating precious resources for your healthcare.

    This country has a problem when people are willing to pay $1000 for custom wheels on their low-rider Hondas but expect to pay 20 bucks to see their doctor.

    It sounds like you have your priorities straight.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s